Last night Bouygues announced a surprise change to tariffs and updated some of its guidance. The new tariffs revolve around discounts for multiple SIMs, and follow on from Iliad’s family plan announcement on 1 October. We give our take on the new plans and the impact to the market in this short piece.
Iliad has posted yet another quarter of good results; key SR trends are all slightly better, as is EBITDAaL inc and ex BTS. For those looking for a read across to SFR results later today, French MSR growth is a touch slower, as are both French fixed and mobile net adds, which could mean SFR has better KPIs but weaker SR trends in our view (albeit the back book changes from SFR could be a key offset).
There has been a lot of focus on the recent change in mobile price points from SFR/Bouygues. Orange has underperformed the CAC40 by c10% over the last 10 days. Most commentary we have seen, seems to worry that the move by SFR will start a new price war at the high end. We think that is probably not going to happen, and explain why in this report. That is good news for Orange, that looks oversold in our view.
Iliad has posted another quarter of good results; SR trends are broadly unchanged, but EBITDA growth has improved materially as French SR drops through at a higher-rate to EBITDA. This is flattered slightly by energy, and BTS distorts the picture, but we estimate underlying EBITDA growth is c10% y/y from +c6% y/y in France.
Iliad continues to perform very nicely in KPI and SR terms in France, Italy and Poland. Group y/y EBITDA trends are slower sequentially however, but the underlying (ex BTS) change is less than the headline delta, but its hard to know what underlying trends are country by country due to lack of disclosure. All of the French operators have now reported apart from SFR; if we assume similar market SR growth to Q3, then it would appear that SFR has had a marginally better quarter in Q4 (SFR report la...
Vodafone’s recent announcement that they are selling their Italian assets to Fastweb will likely have frustrated Xavier Niel, who we know has been keen to do a deal with Vodafone Italy for a number of years. Is this the end of the story? We think it might not be, and if Vodafone won’t sell the asset to him, then maybe he should acquire the whole of Vodafone.
Unfortunately, this report is not available for the investor type or country you selected.
Report is subscription only.
Thank you, your report is ready.
Thank you, your report is ready.