Report
Christian Auzanneau

Accelerating the deployment of the pipeline

Accelerating the deployment of the pipeline

SIGNIFICANT NEWS

The many projects underway will require us to carry out an in-depth review of our model, our figures and our valuation per share. We take a look at the latest news from Courbet.

FACT


Signature of a management agreement in Prague with Accor concerning the Mozart hotel, which will become a Sofitel.
The Collège in Cannes will be rebranded under the Hosho banner as part of an agreement with Louvre Hôtels (Jinjiang group). A building permit has been submitted that will significantly upgrade the site.
The Hollywood hotel in Cannes is up and running and should be fully open for the 2025 summer season.
Projects are progressing at La Bourboule (France). Courbet has other projects under development that will add value for the shareholder.



ANALYSIS

The Hotel Mozart, Prague, has changed Courbet’s profile
Mr OTT, a major shareholder, has brought the Hotel Mozart to Courbet. Courbet has signed a partnership agreement with the Accor group, with the aim of transforming the Mozart into a Sofitel Legend once the major works have been completed. In our opinion, this is one of the finest hotels in Central Europe, housed in a 17th century building. In return for an investment by Courbet of around €15m (AV estimate), this top-class hotel will open in 2027 with a hundred or so rooms and suites to the highest standards of modern luxury. It is easy to estimate the value of this hotel (EV, bricks on top of hotel management) at several tens of millions of euros, a figure to be refined gradually between now and 2027, when delivery is due.
Accor will manage the hotel via a management contract, leaving Courbet full ownership of the asset. Between now and 2027, and during the refitting phase, this asset will not generate any revenue. However, because of its size, it will make a significant contribution to Courbet’s GAV. The financial scope of the transaction will be specified at a later date, including the contribution value of the hotel to Courbet and the related current (and forward) debt.
From 2028, we expect Courbet to be able to use the hotel as collateral for loans to accelerate its development. Initially (2026-27), the Chevenoz development project (see below) could be used to accelerate deployment. As regards the financing of the renovation work at the Mozart, the contract signed with Accor should provide sufficient security to secure bank loans.
La Bourboule
The project is still in progress. Delays in the initial schedule of authorisations, which were initially intended to lead to the opening of a hotel at the end of 2023, have led Courbet to submit an application for authorisation in 2024 in a different format. A further review of the financing and profitability aspects will have to be carried out once the authorisations have been obtained and purged, in the course of 2024 from now on.
Given the weight of Cannes, Prague and Chevenoz, La Bourboule should ultimately make a moderate contribution to the group’s GAV. In our opinion, this also improves the overall risk reward.
Cannes College
The exciting Collège International project is set to accelerate significantly with the submission of an authorisation aimed at doubling the surface area by 6,000 sqm while radically reorganising the building. A partnership with the JinJiang group (also a shareholder in Accor) will boost rental income over the long term. The core of the project is to create an international campus in a renowned destination. The concept chosen (Hosho) is a hybrid one, combining students and foreign tourists in a format similar to that of a youth hostel.
If the necessary authorisations are obtained quickly, the opening will be scheduled for the H2 25.
Launched in 2020, the Hosho concept already exists in Paris (Porte d’Italie). Through a partial offer of collective dormitories, it allows residents to obtain a particularly affordable price/night by working on the spaces and their distribution, and allows the operator to massively increase the number of visitors as well as the income per sqm (density). Courbet has not yet specified the RoI of this investment (or its Yield on Cost), the duration of the planned management contract with JinJiang and the other parameters. An update will be provided once the necessary authorisations have been obtained and the management contract has been secured. Obtaining building rights for 6,000 sqm in Cannes will in itself have a significant NAV value.
For Courbet, Cannes Collège is the Group’s second flagship project after Prague. In proportion to Courbet’s size, it will require a significant investment, the terms of which (equity to be issued, debt) will be specified at a later date. We continue to believe in the value of this plot in Cannes and in the potential of the Cannes Collège project. The concept to be deployed corresponds to the site’s vocation. More generally, and in line with the deployment of the Meninger hotels, for example, offering affordable access to hotels is a real challenge for an industry whose costs have risen sharply in recent years (cf. RevPAR Europe in 2021-23, occupancy ratios, etc.), due to global inflation (energy & wages). In our opinion, there is a real place for this “affordable & friendly” segment in the hotel industry.
Hotel Hollywood Cannes
Completion of the first phase of the works should enable the restaurant and half of the 100 rooms to be open for the 2024 season. The second phase should see the hotel operating at full capacity, with a completely renewed offering, for the 2025 season. This represents a delay on our initial estimates (around 1 year), which we will have to recalibrate without any significant negative impact on our NAV. Following the announcements about Cannes College and Prague it seems likely that Hollywood Cannes will also benefit from a long-term management contract once the works are completed.
Chevenoz
Courbet is rolling out a development project on a 3-hectare site. This development is expected to deliver 17,000 sqm of flats in an area close to the Swiss border (near Evian/Lac Léman), which benefits from the high purchasing power of cross-border commuters and a shortage of land encouraged by the extraordinarily high residential prices in Switzerland. We do not expect this potentially highly profitable project (development margin per sqm applied to 17,000 sqm) to be fully sold out before 2026. The precise metrics of the project (including the financing, size and cost) will only be released once the final permits have been obtained.
Other destinations
In line with Courbet’s strategy and what is underway in La Bourboule (or has been done at Cannes Hollywood), Courbet remains in advanced negotiations for the acquisition of other French hotel to be optimised. The “targets / scope” and “financing” aspects will be clarified as and when they become a reality.


IMPACT

Courbet has a pipeline of projects which, if successful, will provide real leverage for increasing value. At a time when the credit market conditions have tightened for all property-related businesses, Courbet faces a real financing challenge, but it has the advantage of being able to rely on its reference shareholder.
The forthcoming publication of Courbet’s accounts and its Annual General Meeting (AGM held last year on 30 March) will give rise to an in-depth review of our model, including our target price. This will have to take into account the increasing number of positive valuation options, which will of course be subject to financing being put in place. For all the projects in the company’s portfolio, the challenge is to finance several tens of millions of works and acquisitions. Courbet’s current market cap is €22m. Given the current portfolio, Courbet already has a number of attractive projects to work on over the next few years. We conclude that the portfolio is in the process of finalising the first phase of asset aggregation initiated by Mr OTT. The second phase can be expected through profits’ capitalisation (development) or flows (hotels) that will be generated over the next few years.
Throughout the first phase of portfolio development, most of Courbet’s value will rely on its NAV, with little in the way of income The latter will gradually materialise when the units are delivered or sold (in the case of Chevenoz, for example). We are therefore planning a preparation phase from 2024-26, followed by an acceleration in deliveries, revenues and profits from 2027-28. Our estimates will progressively aggregate projects that have received: i/ definitive planning permission and ii/ financing.
Underlying
Courbet S.A.,

Courbet SA. Courbet SA, formerly Societe Anonyme Courbet, is a France-based company engaged in investments in industrial and commercial undertakings and asset management.

Provider
AlphaValue Corporate Services
AlphaValue Corporate Services

AlphaValue Corporate Services capitalise on the research and credit analysis expertise deployed by AlphaValue with major institutional investors at European level over the past nine years. The proprietary tools and processes enabling AlphaValue Corporate Services to establish a valuation and/or a credit risk assessment are identical to those used by AlphaValue to the benefit of its institutional clients. The only difference is the recognition that a company evaluation cannot be dissociated from the fact that the latter is paying for the service (AlphaValue Corporate Services), as opposed to the investor footing the bill (AlphaValue). AlphaValue’s research tools are characterised by the transparency of the valuation methodologies, their responsiveness to market data and by nine years’ experience of a universe numbering more than 450 European companies. Through its coverage and sector exhaustiveness, AlphaValue ranks alongside the major research houses in Europe and constitutes the only new entrant to the European space in the past decade. This significant presence is reflected in an unrivalled distribution capability via platforms commonly adopted by investors to access research: Factset, Bloomberg, Capital IQ and the numerous websites. AlphaValue is one the largest research contributors to these platforms, to the benefit of AlphaValue Corporate Services issuer clients.  The AlphaValue Corporate Services analysts are AlphaValue’s sector specialists. Their robust knowledge of the business models in their sectors enables the rapid generation of incisive, relevant research and advantageous interaction with the management teams.

Analysts
Christian Auzanneau

Other Reports on these Companies
Other Reports from AlphaValue Corporate Services

ResearchPool Subscriptions

Get the most out of your insights

Get in touch